In a prior "review" of Valentines Eye by Kitty LaRoar I commented that since I'm a musician (and not a critic) I don't do reviews. But, here I go again with a "review" of Mike Moynihan and the Creosote Jazz Collective at the 2017 Tucson Jazz Festival (TJF). They played at the Downtown Jazz Fiesta for MLK Day on the Connect Coworking Stage. My reviews are only of performances I like so in that sense, I'm not a critic.
What I liked about Mike Moynihan and his group was the blend of instruments and the beautiful sound they produced. The key to this great sound was Mike's decision to choose vibraphone and guitar for the septet. Listen to the video above. It is just selections from a few pieces, but I hope it gives you a sense of the beautiful sound, blend and interaction achieved by the group. I wish I had a complete recording of the entire hour (Mike tells me he is working on getting the full hour on line). Some beautiful moments, particularly in the endings where Tristan Rogers uses the vibraphone's motor, were missed. I hope at some time in the future, Mike records with this group, maybe even in a live, rather than a studio session. It's not easy to create this great a sound in a live setting and when you succeed it creates an exciting recording.
The interaction between guitarist Matt Mitchell and vibraphonist Tristan Rogers is important to appreciate. The guitar and vibraphone can both be played as chordal instruments. They can also be used to play only single-note, horn-like improvisational lines. Mitchell and Rogers used both approaches and never stepped on each other. Their interaction allowed Mike to sail over the top and allowed the rhythm section (Nathan Hooker on drums and Jack Wood on bass) to stay solid underneath. If you play any of these instruments and are a jazz musician, the Creosote Collective is worth your study.
Mike's first recording, Chronicles, got great reviews (here). You can download a copy of Chronicles from CdBaby here. You can read Mike's biography here.
The Creosote Jazz Collective consists of:
Nathan Hooker - drums
Matt Mitchell - guitar
Michael Moynihan - saxophone
Tristan Rogers - vibraphone
Jack Wood - bass
Selections played at TJF (in set order with composers):
1. Wax and Wayne (Moynihan)
2. The Sickness (Moynihan)
3. The Infinite (Rogers)
4. To The Stars (Moynihan)
5. Kindness (Moynihan)
6: I Have A Dream (Moynihan)
As an extra treat, all the selections were original compositions by Moynihan and Rogers. They were all great! I wish I could play each one of them for you (if Mike gets the full set on line, I'll review each song in a future post)!
Why are there so few black male teachers? Chris Emdin of Columbia University suggests that a cycle of failure haunts students and their teachers (click below to enlarge):
Students act out, so teachers tighten the rules; more restrictions combined with dull and irrelevant curricula cause students to fail, and teachers quit -- thinking it’s their fault.
Gary Burton (who has an on-line jazz course from the Berklee School of Music here) has a simple recommendation for playing ballads: embellish the melody, don't play scales. His argument is that ballad melodies are always given a thoughtful treatment by the composer. If you like the ballad, it's unlikely that your improvisation will improve on it very much.
This is the same approach that Wes Montgomery used:
Improvisation on a given melody is a melodic variation of the established melody. When improvising in the style of Wes Montgomery, it is important to retain enough of the notes of the original melody to maintain the feeling of the tune (Lee Garson, Jimmy Stewart and Charles Stewart, 1968 Wes Montgomery Jazz Guitar Method Robbins Music, New York, page 18).
Gary Burton is playing the song For Heaven Sake (a song made famous by Billy Holiday, hear her version here), which Wes Montgomery also played.
This is not the easiest ballad Gary might have chosen for instruction. The melody has many non-scale tones and goes through three key changes. Here is the figured bass:
(F) ||(V)|| II V | I VIx | II V | I Ix | | IVm bIVm | III bIIIm7b5 | II V | I || || II V | I VIx | II V | I | | Ivm bIVm | III bIIIm7b5 | II V | I || (Db) || II V | I | II V | I (bVo VIIx) | (Eb) | II VIIx | II V | Vm Ix | (F) II V || (F) || II V | I VIx | II V | I Ix | | IVm bIVm | III bIIIm7b5 | II V | I (V) ||
And, here is a nice jam track with chord symbols displayed (there are some minor differences from the figured bass above, but the figured bass shows the repeating II-V-I and linear IVm-bIVm-III-bIII patterns that define the song).
EXERCISES
Write out the melody in the key of F by playing along with a recorded version and transcribing if necessary.
Study Gary Burton's and Wes Montgomery's solos carefully noticing how the melody is embellished but remains in the improvisations, even if only hinted.
Take other well know Jazz Ballads (see the list here that includes jam tracks and chord charts-- available when you choose a song). Use the same approach, first play the melody then elaborate the melody, do not run chord scales).
Take well know Bebop or Swing tunes (for example here) and see if you can use the same approach (melody embellishment). Can you use this simpler approach or, as Gary Burton suggests, is it necessary to run chord scales for these tunes? Let your ear be the guide.
On For Heaven's Sake try another approach: Play only within the major scales defined by the key changes F-Db-Eb-F. Try starting at different points in each scale and playing that mode. For example, starting on the second note (G-G in the F scale) is the Dorian mode. Starting on the sixth note (D-D in the F scale) is the Aeolian. The name of the mode is not as important as hearing that it will sound different. Personally, I like starting on the seventh (E-E in the F scale) which is the Locrian mode (a diminished sounding scale).
Finally, treat the entire song as a modal tune. Construct a scale that uses every note in the tune. Run the scale from D-D using all the non-chordal notes and the Bb in the key of F. How does this sound. Does it work across all the key changes or do you need to be careful?
In my last post (here) I introduced the current project of Joshua Redman & Brad Mehldau. Now, let's do something with that by integrating it in our own playing. Let's take the Jazz Standard The Nearness of You, a Hoagy Carmichael song from 1938. Here's the figured bass:
A: (F) || I | Vm Ix | IV | IVo | III bIIIx | II V | III bIIIx | II V ||
|| I | Vm Ix | IV | IVo | III bIIIx | II V | I bVIIx | I6 ||
B: || II | V | I Vm | Ix | IV | IIIo VIx | II | V ||
A: || I | Vm Ix | IV | IVo | III bIIIx | II V | I (VI | II V) ||
There are lots of special (III-bIIIx or IV-IVo or I-Vm-Ix, etc.) and standard (II-V-I) chord progressions that make the song interesting. There are also parts of the song that could be altered to add interest, for example a modal Gm bridge with the bass pedal on G. And, of course, Mehldau does a lot of interesting things with chord changes throughout the song. There is much to study here.
EXERCISES
If you play a chordal instrument (guitar, vibraphone or piano), find an interested musician who plays a single note instrument (brass or string instrument), make sure you know this song in-and-out, by memory and are comfortable with it (if not, find some other song you are). Then, try a free improvisational session in the style of Joshua Redman and Brad Mehldau. How did it work for you? What did you learn? (If you don't play a chordal instrument, find a guitar, piano or vibraphone player).
Use lines from the Redman-Mehldau version, particularly Brad Mehldau's introduction, and write a new song using those ideas and any parts of the figured bass above you find interesting. Play the song for some other musicians. If you've done this exercise correctly, they should not have been able to identify your new song as The Nearness of You. If you need more inspiration, listen to Milt Jackson's version (below), one of my favorites.
The PBS NewsHour just ran a piece on Joshua Redman's new project with Brad Mehldau. This is really different from his last project with the Bad Plus in that Redman and Mehldau are emphasizing improvisation while The Bad Plus downplayed the improvisatory aspect of their playing. The NewsHour feature was a little frustrating in that they only played brief cuts of Redman and Mehldau improvising. The NewsHour feature really didn't demonstrate Redman and Mehldau's approach to improvisation which involves listening and interacting. The following cut (from SoundCloud) seems to be a good example.
As a brief comparison with Redman's earlier project, The Bad Plus Joshua Redman, try the following piece for comparison.
There is a lot more of Joshua Redman's work to hear on SoundCloud if you are interested:
It might seem at first that Jazz composition would have little to learn from Baroque Music. In an interview with National Public Radio (NPR here), mezzo-soprano Joyce DiDonato helped clarify the issue for me.
NPR was interviewing Ms. DiDonato about her new album In War and Peace: Harmony Through Music. The album is a collection of baroque arias from the 17th and 18th centuries. It is divided into two sections, the first addressing war, the second addressing peace. Two comments DiDonato made in the interview caught my attention.
First, somewhat later in the interview, she said:
There is a purity to the music of the Baroque world. We haven't hit dense harmonies yet. It's not overly complex orchestrations. It's really a chance where the text and the voice get to be center stage. And I think that's a chance for more raw emotion to emerge, because there's so much space for the listener to enter into this music.
DiDonato finds that returning to the earlier, less complex form of classical music allows more raw emotion to emerge and also allows the listener to enter more easily into the music. The same can be said for the transition to modal compositions in Jazz. A great example is Miles Davis' Kind of Blue album, one of the most successful jazz albums ever released. The compositions are modal, meaning very simple chord progressions with improvisations drawn from the actual notes in the melodies (rather than from scales and chord substitutions).
Second, was the process DiDonato used to select the arias for her album.
I was sitting at my piano going through a stack of arias, trying to find repertoire for this, and the Paris attacks had just happened. And I thought, I have to address what's happening today, because these composers from years and centuries ago have already been talking about war and peace.
There is a largely unexplored area of jazz composition where choices of songs on an album are designed to address "what's happening today". Jazz is one of the least popular form of music in the US accounting for just 1.4% of total music consumption (tied, interestingly, with classical music). Joyce DiDonato has revived interest in baroque music by, first, linking it to "what's happening today" and second, by throwing off the stuffy, fat-lady-sings image of opera singers. Jazz musicians take note!
Here is the entire NPR inter interview:
EXERCISES
Pick a current "what's happening today" topic that interests you and that you care deeply about (forget about your love life or the typical topics that are the basis for Rock, R&B and Blues songs). If you don't have any concern about "what's happening today," get concerned!
Go through your jazz collection, the Great American Song Book and the Real Book (your stack of arias) looking for songs that speak to your "what's happening today" concern. It helps if the songs have lyrics and if you know the lyrics. Maybe the song title is corny or dated, but there might be a lyric that speaks to your issue.
Now comes the fun part! Rewrite the song. Change the title: uses some lyrics you like or some phrase that's appropriate to your concern. Simplify the chord progression by looking for the few chords that capture the feeling you are after. Simplify or entirely change the melody so that it fits a modal scale you find particularly interesting and appropriate to the new song. For the solo, improvised sections of the song, pick one or two chords and use the modal scale (not the original chord changes) for improvisation. Next, change the rhythm of the song: turn a swing song into a ballad; turn a ballad into a Bossa Nova; turn a rock song into Latin Beat; turn a blues song into a Hip Hop beat. Pick some rhythm from modern dance music. Forget standard jazz rhythms.
EXTRA CREDIT: Go right to the source. Take the Handel aria Joyce DiDonato sings in the video above (guitar score here, entire aria here, chord progression and melody here) and rewrite it as a modal jazz head (see the figured bass line below).
Why should you bother doing any of this? Here's another quote from Joyce DiDonato:
Music can be a real guiding light towards empathy, and I can't think of any better prescription. Let's put it to the United States of America right now, a country divided. If we had more empathy, that's a healing thing. And music, because it goes to the heart and bypasses the brain, can put people in a position to hear another point of view, to be less afraid of it. I believe a thousand percent that music can do that and this album can help that. I would love for that to be true.
FIGURE BASS
Lascia ch'io piangaAn interesting aspect of this Handel aria is that it was used in a number of operas under different names and slight rearrangements.
(F) || I | II |V | Ix I | IV | V I | IV V | I ||
(G) || I | V I | II (F) I | (C) V | I (I) | I ||
Notice the key changes (in parentheses) and the six measure bridge. Use the lyrics to name the new song:
Lascia ch'io pianga mia cruda sorte, e che sospiri la libertà .
Il duolo infranga queste ritorte de' miei martiri sol per pietà .
Allow that I weep over
my cruel fate,
and that I may sigh
for the freedom
Let my sadness shatter
these chains
of my suffering,
if only out of pity.
I am not a critic and don't write reviews of other musician's work, so technically this post is not a review. But, I just can't help commenting on this album.
If you are a jazz musician, you have to hear this album. It features Kitty LaRoar (vocals), Nick Shankland (piano) and Ed Jones (sax). No drummer. No bass player. I listen to a lot of music but I can't say that I have ever heard an album like this before (you can tell me in the comments if you have). But, I have experienced the feel of this album one time before. It was at the end of a long engagement. The last set. The last song. It was late. The bar was empty except for a small audience, all sitting apart at different tables. It was the last time this group would ever play together. They were all exhausted.
Somehow, the players all managed to dig in and give one final quiet, beautiful last performance of their standard ending tune. The playing was quiet, intense, not an extra note played anywhere, just the distilled essence of a year working together. A peak experience for everyone. No one talked as the group packed up and went home.
This, I have found, is what jazz musicians play for, night after night in rooms with poor acoustics, inattentive audiences, misbehaving equipment and rude club owners. It's that one peak experience. It has only happened to me once.
What is so unusual about "Valentine's Eve" is that every song feels like, and takes me back to, that one night a long time ago in a club I can't remember. I wrote Nick Shankland that, at first I could taste my martini and smell the smoke. After listening to the entire album, it was much more than that. If you are a musician and have never had that peak experience, the only way I could possibly tell you about it is to have you listen to this album. The musicians in the group I played with have never talked with me about that last set. We probably would not know what to say to each other.
The trailer above will give you brief sample. If you like it and get just a little transported or are just a little interest in what a peak playing experience feels like, by all means buy the entire album. Just remember, this is not a review. I'm not a critic and don't write reviews.
P.S. If you are a musician, please pay close attention to the sections where voice, sax and some times piano work in unison. This is not easy. It's especially difficult to play quietly, maintain your intensity and maintain your pitch. I never lost my attention for one minute while listening to this album and I am the most easily distracted person the universe.
